232 years ago, the grandest experiment in self governance in political history was set in motion when 56 men signed their names to an eloquent and daring document whose words still echo in the hearts of free people around the world. No other political document on earth, either before or since, has impacted world history so profoundly than our Declaration of Independence. The only document that even comes close was written eleven years later and is our own Constitution.
The men who wrote the Declaration of Independence did not just write some flowery sounding words. These were not men looking for earmarks and pork. When they signed this Declaration, they did so knowing full well that the consequences could be deadly. The very last sentence of the the Declaration indicates that they knew the weight and significance of their words:
—And for the support of this Declaration, with a firm reliance on the protection of Divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our Fortunes, and our sacred Honor.
Most people never get that far in their reading of the Declaration. If they know anything about it at all it is probably connected with the "Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness" phrase and even then, most people probably assume that particular phrase is part of the Constitution.
As I was contemplating the upcoming Fourth of July Holiday, that last sentence popped into my head. Long ago, I had a US History teacher take time in class to point out that sentence and its importance to us and the Declaration. It was in eighth grade and our teacher was an Estonian immigrant whose parents came here to escape the Nazis. I wish I could remember her name as she had a profound influence upon me and my love for history.
The point to all of this is to compare McCain and Obama and decide which one would sign such a pledge and if they signed it, would they keep their word.
Rather than beat around the proverbial bush, I'll come straight out and say that McCain would sign it and mean it. Obama might sign it it, but as soon as the political heat started rising, I believe he would disavow it as soon as he could. He has a history.
On March 18, 2008, Senator Obama said this:
"I can no more disown him than I can disown the black community. I can no more disown him (Jeremiah Wright) than I can my white grandmother."
Six weeks later, on April 29th, Senator Obama disavowed Wright.
Since his disavowal of his former spiritual adviser, Mr. Obama has since disavowed others and changed his position on a number of issues. Michael Crowley , editor of the New Republic, a center-left publication, pointed this out in an op-ed in the Guardian yesterday:
During the Democratic primary season, all those eons ago, Barack Obama deployed no more powerful line against Hillary Clinton than his insistence that 'we can't just tell people what they want to hear. We need to tell them what they need to hear'. More than just a catchy couplet, the phrase was a deadly arrow into the heart of Clintonism.
Few things crippled Hillary's campaign like the belief that she would say or do anything to get elected, from supporting the Iraq War to claiming she'd dodged sniper fire at Tuzla. In Obama, Democrats seemed to have found something refreshing: a brave truth-teller unmoored to pollsters such as Mark Penn, someone who had spoken out against Iraq the war and could at last restore integrity and honesty to Washington politics.
But since Obama dispatched Clinton, he has seemed rather more attuned to what the people want to hear or perhaps he has simply traded the wants of a liberal audience for those of a more moderate one. Either way, he is treading that reliably time-worn path every nominee follows to the political centre. And the question for Democrats is whether to applaud Obama as a cunning politician who knows how to win or fret that he's given undecided voters reason to think his 'politics of hope' are just politics as usual.
McCain, on the other hand has shown that he doesn't march to any drumbeat but his own. In conversation, I' often described McCain as a bit of a loose cannon, but never have I gotten the impression that his vote or his opinion was for sale and that includes polling results. McCain's experience as a combat pilot, POW and subsequent years of service both in and out of the US Navy and US Senate have molded him into someone who has had to face more than just some angry words. In other words, he isn't afraid of much and he isn't afraid to take unpopular stands if he thinks he's right. I sometimes disagree with his stances, but I respect him for not putting up a finger to check the political wind.
No one is perfect and that goes for McCain. However, if the Declaration were to be signed today, it could be argued that both would sign it given a similar set of circumstances, but there is only one that you could trust to keep his word and it isn't Obama.
VW












